Compare and find a rental that matches your preferences among the 150 fantastic accommodations from more than 10 providers in Fire Island. Each of the vacation rentals from our partner websites are immediately compared on our website so you can save up to 62%.
Recommended Vacation Rentals on Fire Island
Find your perfect vacation rental on Fire Island: from $175 per night
Vacation rentals and apartments with air conditioning
Vacation rentals with Wi-Fi
Apartments and vacation rentals with a kitchen
Popular Rental Amenities on Fire Island
Use filters to search and find an offer meeting your needs among all of the rentals in Fire Island. HomeToGo's data shows that "internet" and "barbecues" are the most commonly provided amenities in Fire Island. Plan your vacation in advance if you love sweating the stress away in saunas or you want a rental with a balcony or a patio. There are just 1 listed accommodations with "saunas" and 1 properties with "balconies/patios."
The Weather on Fire Island
- Rainy days
The above is a climate diagram for Fire Island. July is the warmest month on Fire Island with average maximum temperatures of 84°. January is the coolest month, with average minimal temperature reaching 24°. The rainiest month is December while the driest month is September.
Receive exclusive offers, inspirational stories, and travel regulation updates.
Become a subscriber* and receive great tips on travel planning sent to your inbox!
Enter email address*
Accommodations for your vacation on Fire Island
In Fire Island, two-thirds of the property types are house rentals, which represent 71.43% of its accommodations being offered. Interestingly, specific accommodation type, this type of accommodation in particular is $1,040 a night, with an average size of 2,190 ft². Moreover, the majority of house rentals in this destination can welcome 10 people, which makes it a great vacation spot for large groups. Apartment rentals represent the second most common accommodation option on Fire Island. Apartment rentals in Fire Island are 800 ft² on average, with prices averaging $672 per night.
Enjoy quiet days and lively nights with a Fire Island vacation home
Enjoy a luxurious sea view apartment or a quaint country cottage with a pool on Fire Island. Discover a slower pace of life within the island’s many vibrant hamlets.
Where to find the best food on Fire Island?
Great food and sea views on Fire Island
Fire Island has plenty to ignite the gastronomic passions of anyone who visits. Matthew's Seafood House is a particular favorite, serving up only the best local fish and organizing its famous Thursday night Margarita Madness events.
Other highlights include the Island Mermaid on Ocean Beach, the Kismet Inn and Marina, and The Hideaway on Evergreen Walk. On Fire Island, you’ll find the perfect destinations for casual waterfront dining in any season, whatever your budget.
What are the best nightlife spots on Fire Island?
Hitting the town in Fire Island
Despite its small proportions, Fire Island is somewhat famous for its nightlife and entertainment. The villages of Kismet and Ocean Bay Park are both well known for their party-going atmosphere, with the latter home to Flynn's, a popular waterfront eatery and nightclub.
The main tourist destination of Ocean Beach Village hosts many events that spill onto the streets in the summer months. Here, you’ll also find the Sand Bar, another popular attraction for visitors and certainly one of the most lively places on the island.
Where are the unique attractions on Fire Island?
Explore Fire Island and much more
If you’re looking for something a little more athletic, there are plenty of activities to choose from in the areas around your holiday accommodation. For example, the island’s large stretches of coastline are perfect for surfing and swimming.
At the western end of the island, Robert Moses State Park has a pitch and putt golf course with 18 holes. It’s also an ideal destination for swimming, surfing, fishing, and clamming.
How much does it cost to rent a vacation rental on Fire Island?
The average nightly price for vacation rentals on Fire Island is $175.
How many vacation rentals are available to book on Fire Island?
There are currently 150 vacation homes on Fire Island to browse and book for your next trip.
What amenities are most popular for vacation homes on Fire Island?
Most travelers search for internet, barbecues, and TVs when booking a vacation rental on Fire Island.
How many vacation rentals are on Fire Island?
Fire Island has 150 House rentals and Apartment rentals on offer to rent.
Are pets allowed in vacation rentals on Fire Island?
Finding a cabin rental on Fire Island that allows dogs is definitely possible, with 36 pet-friendly homes on offfer.
What's the best time of year to travel to Fire Island?
If booking a vacation rental on Fire Island, consider that rainy season is usually in December or February, with September often being the driest.
We list offers from thousands of providers, including: